SaaS Critique

Software reviews that tell you when to skip it.

Best lists, top tens and scored reviews for every kind of business software. Each one ends in a plain verdict: buy, try first or skip.

The best kanban board you can buy, and not much more than that.
Buy
Does nearly everything, which is exactly the problem.
Try first
Still easy to use. No longer easy to recommend.
Skip

Find software by category

All categories

Marketing

Sales

  • CRM1
  • Sales engagement
  • Lead generation
  • Proposals and e-signature
  • Ecommerce

Work management

Customer support

  • Help desk
  • Live chat and chatbots
  • Knowledge base
  • Customer feedback

Finance

  • Accounting
  • Invoicing and billing
  • Expense management
  • Payroll

HR and people

  • HR software
  • Recruiting
  • Time tracking
  • Learning and training

Design and content

  • Design
  • Video editing
  • Website builders
  • Forms and surveys

IT and development

  • Developer tools
  • Security
  • Cloud hosting
  • Monitoring
  • Data and analytics

AI tools

  • AI writing
  • AI assistants
  • AI image and video
  • AI for sales and support

Latest best lists

All 1 best lists

Latest verdicts

All 6 reviews
  • Trello

    Project management

    The best kanban board you can buy, and not much more than that.

    Buy 8.0
  • Notion

    Docs and wikis

    A brilliant workspace that still makes you build your own project tool.

    Try first 7.9
  • ClickUp

    Project management

    Does nearly everything, which is exactly the problem.

    Try first 7.8
  • The free CRM is a gift. The upgrade path is where they collect.

    Try first 7.6
  • Asana

    Project management

    Polished and dependable, but you pay a premium for the polish.

    Try first 7.6
  • Mailchimp

    Email marketing

    Still easy to use. No longer easy to recommend.

    Skip 6.3

How a score is built

Each product gets five marks out of ten. We weight them, add them up and publish the working, so you can disagree with us on the evidence.

  • Buy8.0 and upWorth paying for if it fits your case.
  • Try first6.5 to 7.9Good, with a catch. Test it before you commit.
  • SkipBelow 6.5Better options exist for most buyers.
  • 25%Value for money. What you pay against what you get, including the plan most teams end up on.
  • 25%Features. How much of the job the product covers without add-ons.
  • 20%Ease of use. How quickly a new person can do useful work in it.
  • 15%Room to grow. Whether it still works when the team and the workload double.
  • 15%Support and trust. Support quality, pricing stability and how the vendor treats customers.